close
close

Mondor Festival

News with a Local Lens

Casagrande: How good is Alabama? We’re about to find out
minsta

Casagrande: How good is Alabama? We’re about to find out

This is an opinion column.

In college football, there is a lot of talk about eye testing. This perfectly vague evaluation measure, almost deliberately indefinable, has a certain weight in this sport.

Who is good?

Who is playoffs GOOD?

This is a bit like the Supreme Court’s view on pornography. Justice Potter Stewart used the quote “I know it when I see it” in 1964 that made him the father of the eye exam movement.

That brings us to Alabama football and his eye rating.

Granted, some readers may have found something exciting about LSU’s 42-13 win Saturday. This wasn’t Times Square in the 70s, but we think some of you knew that when you saw it.

But did the College Football Playoff selection committee do it?

Sports’ highest court has iPads full of videos – so contradictory and so far from definitive. It goes nationwide, week to week, game to game, it doesn’t make sense.

Because there is so little consistency anywhere.

Tennessee, for example, is the second highest-rated team in the SEC in the latest AP poll, at No. 6. The Vols are 8-1, but that loss was to an Arkansas team that is 5-4 overall. Two spots down is Notre Dame, another 8-1 team whose only loss is to… a team that is tied for seventh in the MAC.

Both will be safe in the second version of the CFP transparency ranking should be released with a fake version on Tuesday evening.

Alabama will be too, but we’re headed down a path of eye tests and top-secret committee data. They’ll look at three SEC teams with two losses — Alabama, Georgia and Mississippi — looking for ways to differentiate the trio.