close
close

Mondor Festival

News with a Local Lens

Iowa women’s anger over abortion ban wasn’t enough to win Harris
minsta

Iowa women’s anger over abortion ban wasn’t enough to win Harris

When people think of Iowaif they think about it, they think of it as a place where their grandparents live. Where there’s pink carpet in the bathroom, a green bean casserole on the table for Thanksgiving, and Folgers brewing in the coffee maker that Grandma bought before you were born but won’t replace it because it works always. They just don’t do things the way they used to. Iowa means being sent home with a Ziploc bag of cookies and a Tupperware container of leftovers. Iowa is baseball, corn and gas station pizza.

And Iowa is nice. We pride ourselves on our kindness – the way we hold doors open and apologize even when the other person inconveniences us.

Iowa is not the place people think of when they think of a hotbed of seething rage.

Iowa is not the place people think of when they think of a hotbed of seething rage.

But I have to tell you something: your grandmother in Iowa is pissed. She is furious. And, depending on her views on reproductive justice, she might pick a fight with your grandfather.

A survey published on Saturday by Selzer & Co. found that Trump was down 19 points among Iowa seniors. Senior women surveyed supported Harris by a margin of more than two to one: 63% to 28%. Iowa’s senior men also favored Harris, but by only 2 percentage points: 47% to 45%. According to the Des Moines Register, “The poll shows that women – particularly those who are older or politically independent – ​​are driving the late shift to Harris. »

This trend reversed in favor of Trump with Trump wins state and presidential re-election, according to the NBC News projection. Yet when the results showed at one point Harris led Trump 47% to 44% in deep red Iowa, it shocked the nation. Neither candidate has campaigned in Iowa since the primaries. Iowa is a rapidly aging state with approximately 1.1 million people aged 50 or overAnd Trump won it by 8 points in 2020. All members and senators of the United States House of Representatives are Republicans, we have a Republican governor, and Republicans control the House of Representatives. Conventional political wisdom held that it was a given that Trump would win Iowa in a jiffy.

Harris didn’t win Iowa. But we must not neglect the anger of our mothers and grandmothers, their rage at being once again forced into the role of second-class citizens by politicians who only see us as incubators of a future tax base. State grandmothers remember those who had to travel to Mexico for abortions, who contracted life-threatening infections and who found themselves stuck on a farm raising their children, unable to leave their husbands or even contract a line of credit. Women 65 and older, these radical grandmothers, are the second wave of feminists who fought for reproductive rights, and now they have to start all over again.

On June 28, The Iowa State Supreme Court upheld a near-total ban on abortion. Although there are exceptions for rape, incest and maternal life, experts and doctors have emphasized that these exceptions exist in name only. Iowa is also a state that ranks 50th in the nation for OB-GYN access (meaning we have the fewest such doctors per capita) and we have a rising maternal mortality rate even before the 2022 Dobbs decision that overturned Roe v. Wade. What is happening in Iowa is not a new reality, but an old reality. And Iowans, the majority of whom support access to abortion in all or most circumstances, remember what it was like before we had this right.

Greta Mullberg, a Marion resident, told me via email, “I’m 75 and I remember this. more than one friend had an abortion. For this they had to go to Puerto Rico. you had to have money and, even then, the conditions were not good. A friend contracted a serious infection and was never able to have children. we will not go back!!!”

In 2020, Beverly Young, then 82, told me about the humiliation of trying to get a prescription for birth control in 1963 and being asked if she had her husband’s permission. She remembers friends having abortions before it was legal and enduring the pain and fear.

Speaking about women 65 or older voting for Harris, Liz Flemming, an Iowa activist, wrote on Threads on Sunday: “My mother is one of those women. Many of our mothers are these women. They saw Roe v. Wade adopt in 1973, then watched their daughters and granddaughters lose that right in 2022. Then they watched our state and legislature ignore our health and freedom to pass a 6-week abortion ban that leaves us already struggling.

Whatever platitudes and reassurances Republicans try to use to appease women ring hollow as Iowans remember the realities of the past, now confirmed by securities about women dying because they I couldn’t access necessary health care.

Whatever platitudes and reassurances Republicans try to use to appease women ring hollow as Iowans remember the realities of the past.

Kira Barker, executive director of the Polk County Democrats, who went door-to-door and organized for Democratic candidates, told me another motivating factor was that Iowans had become ground zero for Democratic candidates. the Project 2025 agenda. In addition to passing an abortion ban, Republicans have pushed through a school voucher program And reduced SNAP benefitsall parts of the Conservative plan, and people just don’t like it.

Democratic Senator Megan Srinivasa doctor, also points out that Iowa has in the past been a swing state. She noted that elected officials and party organizers have opted for a “bottom-up” messaging approach, which emphasizes issues that voters care about rather than the party’s “top-down” message. “Iowans are truly purple and are striving to do what is best for their families and communities rather than being tied to a partisan identity.”

And yet, NBC News exit polls found that first-time male voters went for Trump over Harris between 62% and 36% — a striking difference.

People who remember what the past was really like will do their best in Iowa to try to make sure we don’t go back there again. But if these elections are to be believed, the fight is far from over.