The idea of ​​Soto signing with the Blue Jays might seem like “Canadian wishful thinking” for four reasons:

Reason one: financial constraints and competing big spenders

The Mets, Yankees and even the Red Sox have shown a willingness to spend large sums on high-profile players, positioning themselves as Soto’s financial favorites. Mets owner Steve Cohen, known for his aggressive pursuit of talent, is unlikely to be outbid, especially with a superstar like Soto on the table.

Likewise, despite reservations about increasing payroll, the Yankees have shown a willingness to match higher deals when they believe a player is critical to their success, as demonstrated by Aaron Judge. In contrast, as the Blue Jays have signed larger contracts in recent years, the extent of investment required for Soto far exceeds that of previous high-profile signings like George Springer or Kevin Gausman.

Second reason: competitive situation and reconstruction needs

After a disappointing 74-88 season, the Blue Jays face key questions about their long-term direction. While they have stars like Vladimir Guerrero Jr., there is uncertainty about his tenure beyond 2025. Soto might be hesitant to join a team without a clear and immediate championship on the horizon. This is something more established in markets like Boston, New York or even Los Angeles, if the Dodgers go into bidding.

Third reason: marketing and cultural appeal

Soto has already played in the media spotlight for New York fans alongside Yankees star Aaron Judge. A re-signing in New York could tap Soto for marketing opportunities and generate fan excitement. Boston can also highlight its history with Dominican stars like David Ortiz, potentially appealing to Soto’s sense of cultural heritage. Although diverse and dynamic, at first glance, Toronto does not have the same level of visibility and baseball tradition as these major American markets.

Reason 4: Toronto lacks the appetite for aggressive spending

Toronto would likely have to offer a record contract to secure Soto, breaking their usual spending limits. MLB insiders wonder if the Blue Jays front office is ready to make such a bold move, especially without guaranteed championship potential. Toronto’s historically conservative financial approach could make it unlikely the team will “outbid” more aggressive franchises.

The Bottom Line: It’s Likely Soto Will Probably Land in New York

Ultimately, while the Blue Jays’ interest is understandable, signing Soto would require a massive financial outlay, a compelling competitive plan and a level of spending aggressiveness unusual for their front office. Soto’s arrival in Toronto seems more like a hopeful speculation than a likely acquisition.