There’s nothing like sinking into a comfy movie theater seat and immersing yourself in a big-screen adventure, preferably with a bucket of popcorn in tow. Of course, the theater experience can sometimes be ruined by inconsiderate neighbors munching on snacks, talking or pulling out their cell phones and giving us strange blue light distractions. Many of these issues have kept people from going to the movies in recent years, and we’re only now getting to a point where people are coming back for landmark films like the well revised Moana II And well revised Nasty Part 1.

So imagine my surprise when people like Dwayne Johnson And Cynthia Erivo came out this week to defend people who sing in the theater in their respective musicals. Like, honestly, what the fuck?

What Dwayne Johnson and Cynthia Erivo said about singing in film